Why a personal pension plan might be better

Auto-enrolment sounds like a great idea, and it's certainly a huge step in the right direction for workers in Ireland without a pension. But depending on your personal circumstances - especially your income tax bracket - you might be much better off with a private pension arrangement, or joining an existing employer pension scheme.
 
Below, you can see how an auto-enrolled employee would have a net cost of €300 to achieve a €700 contribution to their pension. A higher-rate taxpayer can achieve the same €700 pension contribution at a net cost of €240 after income tax relief, assuming a similar employer contribution.

Auto-enrolment

No personal pension scheme

Personal pension

20% taxpayer

Personal pension

40% taxpayer

Employee contributes:
€300
€400
€400
Employer contributes*:
€300
€300*
€300*
Government contribution:
€100
€0
€0
Income tax relief**:
€0
€80
€160
Total contribution:
€700
€700
€700
Net cost to employee:
€300
€320
€240

*Employer contribution is an estimate for comparison purposes. Employers may contribute more or less than this figure.
**Income Tax relief is not guaranteed. You can get tax relief if your income is taxed under Schedule E or Schedule D (case I or II).
Income tax relief and other values are correct as of September 2025.